As noted in an earlier post, on the Friday evening of 2022's Annual Conference of the Methodist Church in Ireland, I and two others led three groups of Conference members on a reflective walk around the centre of Belfast. The full "script" of the event will appear on the IrishMethodist website, but a few of the pieces used have previously appeared here and 3 can be found in my book of poetry "Doodlings and Doggerel." I thought, however that I would post the new pieces here over the next few days.
Conference this year took place in Assembly Buildings, the headquarters and conference centre of the Presbyterian Church in Ireland, one of our sister denominations on the island. The closest stopping point on our walk is a significant one for the history of that tradition in this island and city. Just across Fisherwick Place is the Royal Belfast Academical Institution, known locally as Inst; a boys’ grammar school, which is arguably the main rival to our own Methodist College Belfast, or "Methody", in terms of rugby. It shares another similarity with Methody in that originally both were not only schools but also theological colleges aimed at training clerics, with Inst being the theological college for Presbyterians until the middle of the 19th century. It ultimately stopped being so in no small part due to the campaigning of the man depicted by the statue outside the front gate of the school, standing with its back to it… Known locally as the “Black Man”, even though the statue is green, It commemorates the early 19th century conservative Presbyterian cleric Henry Cooke. Cooke was a complex man. He was a strong advocate for the poor in the developing city of Belfast and across Ireland, but he was also a ruthless demagogue and an implacably anti-Catholic supporter of Orangeism (although he himself was never an Orangeman)… But his antipathy to Inst was because he was also a firm opponent of the Arianism (denial of the deity of Christ) that was developing in Presbyterianism at that time under the auspices of those here and the Church of Scotland who were described as followers of the “New Light” – growing out of the rationalism of the enlightenment… This mindset also resulted in the revolutionary movements at the end of the 18th and into the early 19th century including the United Irishmen, to which Cooke was also opposed. It has been questioned whether he was actually primarily opposed to these revolutionary ideas, with their sense of tolerance for all beliefs including Catholicism, or to Arianism itself, as his earlier writings didn’t seem particularly evangelical or pro-the 17th century Westminster Confession of Faith, which became the test of orthodoxy for Presbyterians… But, what and whichever, his campaigning set in train a form of conservatism which resulted in the fracturing of the Presbyterians into what became the smaller Non-Subscribing Presbyterians, who wanted no absolute test of orthodoxy and maintained that radical identity, and the more inherently conservative Presbyterian Church in Ireland, our hosts this week. The latter who set up their own colleges in Derry, which became Magee College, now part of Ulster University, and Assemblies College in Belfast, which became Union College after it essentially absorbed Magee, where most of my era of minister took some of their classes in training.
Cooke was and is a divisive character… some saw and see him as a paragon of orthodoxy… some as a populist who used division for his own ends. We may each have our own opinions, but we are not his judge, although we have to make our own call on issues of perceived truth and unity… both of which are affirmed in scripture.
However, what is sometimes not known is that the Black Man is NOT the Black Man… Because it was not this statue that was originally called the Black Man, but the one that stood here for 20 years before this was erected by supporters of Cooke in 1875… The previous statue, which was a blackened bronze statue was one of Lord Belfast the second son of the third Marquis of Donegall who was a romantic poet, novelist, and composer who died in Naples of scarlet fever at the age of 25. A very different character…
NEW TESTAMENT READING
I … beg you to lead a life worthy of the calling to which you have been called, with all humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love, making every effort to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace. There is one body and one Spirit, just as you were called to the one hope of your calling, one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is above all and through all and in all. But each of us was given grace according to the measure of Christ’s gift... The gifts he gave were that some would be apostles, some prophets, some evangelists, some pastors and teachers, to equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the body of Christ, until all of us come to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to maturity, to the measure of the full stature of Christ.
Ephesians 4: 1-7, 11-13
POEM
Who do we put on a pedestalAnd promote as paragons?Those of blackened bronzeForged in the fire of certainties?Those who mark out the junctionsBetween one way and another?Who forever turn their backOn those who dare to question?Or the one who stepped downFrom his elevated positionTo tell stories to sinners andAllow doubters to touch him?Who stretched pierceable skinOver an eternal frameSo that he could hold outHis arms in embrace?
Selah
Comments